How to Write an Academic Book Review
This article "Writing the Academic Book Review" was originally written by Belcher to aid participants in a workshop sponsored by the UCLA Chicano Studies Research Center in February 2003 and to encourage book review submissions to Aztlán: A Journal of Chicano Studies. Book reviews in the field of Chicano studies can be sent to the journal; for information, see the new submissions page. The article was updated in 2015. Cite as Belcher, Wendy Laura. 2003. "Writing the Academic Book Review." Los Angeles, CA: UCLA Chicano Studies Research Center. Last Modified 2015. Retrieved from http://www.wendybelcher.com/writing-advice/how-to-write-book-review/ on [month year].
Why Write a Book Review?
Writing book reviews is not only the easiest and quickest route to publication, it is a good way to improve your writing skills, develop your analytical skills, learn how the journal publishing process works, and get to know editors. Since some libraries can’t buy books unless they have been reviewed and many individuals won’t buy books unless they have read a review, reviewing books can definitely advance your field. Indeed, scholars in smaller fields sometimes get together and assign books for review so that every book published in their field is reviewed somewhere. Just remember that book reviews do not “count” as much on a curriculum vitae as an academic essay. If you are doing more than two book reviews a year, you may be spending too much time on book reviews and not enough on your other writing.
Choosing a Book
Think about what kind of book would be most useful to you in writing your dissertation, finalizing a paper for publication, or passing your exams. Since book reviews do take time, like any writing, it is best to chose a book that will work for you twice, as a publication and as research. Alternatively, some recommend that graduate students focus on reviewing textbooks or anthologies, since such reviews take less background knowledge and editors can find it difficult to find people willing to do such reviews. Although the traditional book review is of one book, editors will often welcome book reviews that address two or more related books--called a review essay.
Choose a book that (1) is in your field, (2) is on a topic for which you have sound background knowledge, (3) has been published in the past two or three years, and (4) has been published by a reputable publisher (i.e., any press affiliated with a university or large commercial presses).
Books on hot topics are often of special interest to editors. It can also be rewarding to pick an obscure but useful book in order to bring attention to it. To avoid complications, it is best not to review books written by your advisor, spouse, or ex!
To identify a suitable book in your field:
- Look up the call number of the favorite book in your field and go to the stacks of your university library. Do a shelf search around the call number to see if anything similar or related has been published in the past couple of years.
- Go to any book database—your university library on-line, Worldcat, Amazon.com, the Library of Congress—and search using two or three keywords related to your field (e.g., Chicano fiction, Chicana politics, Latino demographics, Latina high school education) to find books in your area.
- Read magazines that review books before publication—such as Choice, Library Journal, or Kirkus Reviews—to get a sense for interesting books that will be coming out. You can get copies of books for review before they are published. Editors especially like reviews of just published books.
- Read those academic journals that list books recently received for review or recently published in their area.
- Ask faculty members in your department for recommendations.
Once you have identified several books, locate copies and skim them. Pick the book that seems the strongest. Do not pick a book that has major problems or with which you disagree violently. As a graduate student, you do not have the protection of tenure and may one day be evaluated by the person whose book you put to the ax. If you really feel strongly that you must write a negative review of a certain book, go ahead and write the review. Academia is, after all, quite oedipal and young scholars do sometimes make their reputations by deflating those who came before them. Just realize that going on record in such a public way may have consequences.
Choosing a Journal
Identify several leading journals in your field that publish book reviews. One way to do this is to search an on-line article database or something like Book Review Digest, if your library has access. Using several key words from your field, limit your search to book reviews and note the journals where the results were published.
Before starting to write your review, contact the book review editor of one of the journals. This is important standard practice; in particular because most journals do not accept unsolicited reviews. You do not want to write an entire review of a book and send it to a journal, only to be told that they don't accept unsolicited reviews or that a review of that very book is to appear in the next issue.
So, send a short e-mail to book review editors at prospective journals (most journals have websites with such information) identifying the book you would like to review and your qualifications for reviewing it. This e-mail need not be longer than two sentences: “I am writing to find out if you would welcome a review from me of [Book Title], edited by [editor] and published in 2012 by [pubisher]. I am currently writing my dissertation at Stanford on the history of the field of [name of a field related to book].”
Another reason why you want to contact the book review editor is that they often can get you the book for free. Publishers frequently send books for review straight to journals or, if the book editor directly contacts them, straight to you. Of course, you don’t need to wait for the book to start your review if you have access to a library copy. If you get a free book, make sure to write the review. A book review editor will never send you another book if you don’t deliver on the first.
If the book review editor says yes, they would like a review of the book from you, make sure to ask if the journal has any book review submission guidelines. In particular, you want to make sure you understand how long their book reviews tend to be.
If the book review editor says the book is already under review, move on to your next journal choice or ask the editor if they have any books on the topic that they would like reviewed. You are under no obligation to review a book they suggest, just make sure to get back to them with a decision. It is perfectly acceptable to say “Thanks for the suggestion, I’ve decided to focus on writing my prospectus/dissertation.”
Reading the Book
It is best, when writing a book review, to be an active reader of the book. Sit at a desk with pen and paper in hand. As you read, stop frequently to summarize the argument, to note particularly clear statements of the book’s argument or purpose, and to describe your own responses. If you have read in this active way, putting together the book review should be quick and straightforward. Some people prefer to read at the computer, but if you’re a good typist, you often start typing up long quotes from the book instead of analyzing it. Paper and pen provides a little friction to prevent such drifting.
Take particular note of the title (does the book deliver what the title suggests it is going to deliver?), the table of contents (does the book cover all the ground it says it will?), the preface (often the richest source of information about the book), and the index (is it accurate, broad, deep?).
Some questions to keep in mind as you are reading:
- What is the book’s argument?
- Does the book do what it says it is going to do?
- Is the book a contribution to the field or discipline?
- Does the book relate to a current debate or trend in the field and if so, how?
- What is the theoretical lineage or school of thought out of which the book rises?
- Is the book well-written?
- What are the books terms and are they defined?
- How accurate is the information (e.g., the footnotes, bibliography, dates)?
- Are the illustrations helpful? If there are no illustrations, should there have been?
- Who would benefit from reading this book?
- How does the book compare to other books in the field?
- If it is a textbook, what courses can it be used in and how clear is the book’s structure and examples?
It can be worthwhile to do an on-line search to get a sense for the author’s history, other books, university appointments, graduate advisor, and so on. This can provide you with useful context..
Making a Plan
Book reviews are usually 600 to 2,000 words in length. It is best to aim for about 1,000 words, as you can say a fair amount in 1,000 words without getting bogged down. There’s no point in making a book review into a 20-page masterpiece since the time would have been better spent on an academic essay that would count for more on your c.v.
Some say a review should be written in a month: two weeks reading the book, one week planning your review, and one week writing it.
Although many don’t write an outline for an essay, you should really try to outline your book review before you write it. This will keep you on task and stop you from straying into writing an academic essay.
Classic book review structure is as follows:
- Title including complete bibliographic citation for the work (i.e., title in full, author, place, publisher, date of publication, edition statement, pages, special features [maps, color plates, etc.], price, and ISBN.
- One paragraph identifying the thesis, and whether the author achieves the stated purpose of the book.
- One or two paragraphs summarizing the book.
- One paragraph on the book’s strengths.
- One paragraph on the book’s weaknesses.
- One paragraph on your assessment of the book’s strengths and weaknesses.
Writing the Review
Once you’ve read the book, try to spend no more than one or two weeks writing the review. Allowing a great deal of time to fall between reading the book and writing about it is unfair to you and the author. The point of writing something short like a book review is to do it quickly. Sending a publication to a journal is always scary, sitting on the review won’t make it less so.
Avoiding Five Common Pitfalls
- Evaluate the text, don’t just summarize it. While a succinct restatement of the text’s points is important, part of writing a book review is making a judgment. Is the book a contribution to the field? Does it add to our knowledge? Should this book be read and by whom? One needn’t be negative to evaluate; for instance, explaining how a text relates to current debates in the field is a form of evaluation.
- Do not cover everything in the book. In other words, don’t use the table of contents as a structuring principle for your review. Try to organize your review around the book’s argument or your argument about the book.
- Judge the book by its intentions not yours. Don’t criticize the author for failing to write the book you think that he or she should have written. As John Updike puts it, “Do not imagine yourself the caretaker of any tradition, an enforcer of any party standards, a warrior in any ideological battle, a corrections officer of any kind.”
- Likewise, don’t spend too much time focusing on gaps. Since a book is only 200 to 500 pages, it cannot possibly address the richness of any topic. For this reason, the most common criticism in any review is that the book doesn’t address some part of the topic. If the book purports to be about ethnicity and film and yet lacks a chapter on Latinos, by all means, mention it. Just don’t belabor the point. Another tic of reviewers is to focus too much on books the author did not cite. If you are using their bibliography just to display your own knowledge it will be obvious to the reader. Keep such criticisms brief.
- Don’t use too many quotes from the book. It is best to paraphrase or use short telling quotes within sentences.
For further advice about writing for publication, see Writing Your Journal Article in Twelve Weeks: A Guide to Academic Publishing Successby Wendy Laura Belcher (Sage, 2009).
Writing the Academic Book Review
I no longer teach this course , but you might want to think about teaching it, so I provide the information here.
This workshop aids students in actually writing and publishing a book review for a peer-reviewed journal. At the first session, students receive instruction on why graduate students should (or should not) write book reviews, how to choose a book for review, how to chose a journal for submission, how to read a book for review, how to plan and structure a book review, and five common pitfalls of reviewing. Students also form small groups to discuss the book each plans to review.At the second meeting, students bring a draft of their book review for exchange and feedback. At the third meeting, students arrive with a final version of their essay to submit to an editor for publication.
This workshop is sometimes offered by a particular journal with the editors serving on a panel the first night to provide students with specific advice for submitting reviews to their journal. I did such a workshop for Aztlán: A Journal of Chicano Studies, with the editors Chon A. Noriega and Alicia Gaspar de Alba.
Session 1, Week 1
- Introduction to book reviewing
- Selecting an appropriate book to review
- Five essential elements of any book review
- Typical errors graduate student reviewers make
Session 2, Week 10
- Assignment: First draft due
- Discussion of the writing process and challenges
- Exchanging and critiquing first drafts
- Some instructions on revising
Session 3, Week 16
- Assignment: Final draft due
- Discussion of the writing process and challenges
- Working with editors and the publication process
WHAT IS A BOOK REVIEW?
A book review is a type of a custom written paper that helps students to obtain the essential knowledge and skills they need in order to be successful in creative writing and particularly in analyzing specific texts and global ideas. For the quality review writing, it is very important to know how this type of paper writing differs from writing reports on specific literary works. Both of these genres of professional academic writing are similar but not quite the same. For report writing, it is usually enough to just give a brief summary and some information about the characters. Writing a review, however, takes a lot more time and energy because it requires an extremely detailed research. This kind of college paper writing is really complex, and it could be rather troublesome for some students. In these cases, even the tiniest hints and details hidden in a literary piece are coming into focus. Students have to describe every single problem and evaluate the importance of a chosen source for academic writing in general.
Thus, with so many different requirements, there is no wonder some students start making “how to write an academic book review UK” or “do my assignment for me”-like queries on the web. Sometimes, the professional assistance is absolutely necessary, and there is no need to be ashamed of asking for help when you are overloaded. If your task seems impossible to accomplish within the time given, do not fret! Pro-Papers is at your service 24/7, and our experts will gladly help you get rid of the writing burden.
HOW TO WRITE A BOOK REVIEW WITHIN THE SHORT DEADLINE?
If a student wants to know how to do a book review perfectly, he or she needs to read the whole thing in order to understand everything the author has written about. In regard to college paper writing, this type of custom written paper has been created mainly with a purpose to find out how much students can learn from the sources they read. In order to prove your teacher that you are a hardworking student who is willing to learn how to make a book review qualitatively, you need to put a lot of effort in the assignment you are given.
Book review writing is a significant part of a student's academic success, which is why such tasks require good research skills and professional academic writing experience. Also, it is imperative for the student to have enough time to read the chosen text a few times and analyze it properly. However, what if your deadline does not allow you to approach the task in a proper manner? Do you have no choice but to get a bad mark? Not necessarily, and here are a few reasons why.
Firstly, you can try saving some time on reading and simply look for academic book reviews online. If the literary piece you have chosen is a pretty popular one, it is unlikely you will have troubles finding reviews on it on the web. However, without reading the text, it will be hard for you to know whether the appraisal you have found is objective enough. Although in case some of your friends or parents are familiar with the piece, you can try consulting them on the assessment you have found. Unfortunately, such option is far from good, as you will basically paraphrase someone’s critique, and present it as your own. If this is not the first time your teacher gives review assignments, he will probably notice that your paper is not original, which means you cannot expect a nice grade.
If you are ready to spend money on paid book review services, there is a higher chance for you to get more than a B- for the assignment. Yes, some of those services are not the most reliable ones. And, in case you want to purchase book reviews, you need to make sure the chosen service can be trusted. While there is no easy way to make the reliability check, there are a few things you should pay attention to. First of all, take a look at the policies and the guarantees of the company. Unless you are promised plagiarism-free work written according to the instructions you provide, it is better not to order your paper on the website. Also, if there is not mention of money-back guarantee, or, at least, revisions-upon-request option, this is certainly not the company to buy book reviews online from.
Another thing you should pay attention to are the prices. In case the service is way too cheap, your paper will most likely be written by an undergraduate. Yet, if the service is too expensive, there is just no need to waste money. Such company can hardly offer something so significant, you will not find it anywhere else for a better price. Therefore, try choosing the website with moderate prices but at the same time, quality services and solid guarantees. Also, take a critical look at the customer service. Book reviews quality may not depend on it, but it is always better when you can contact someone and receive clarifications and answers to your questions straight away. If the support or the managers are patient with you and are willing to provide required explanations, it means that the company cares about its clients.
Anyway, if you do not feel like wasting time looking for the trustworthy service, we are glad to inform you that you have already found it. Pro-Papers is the ultimate choice of thousands of students from various academic facilities. We want to solve all your problems in regard to preparing various custom written papers and make sure that your academic career constantly grows. Hence, be sure to check our guarantees and benefits, and get ready to order the best work from us!
BENEFITS OF OUR BOOK REVIEW SERVICE
Sometimes, students are afraid of getting paid help from writing services, as they do not know what to expect from the company they have never worked with before. And, when the services the company offers are prepaid, it feels like there are just too many risks. Will the paper be completed as requested and on time? Will it be prepared at all? Who will be the writer?
Being in the writing niche for many years, we have learned the main concerns our new customers have, and do our best every day to prove our credibility. That is why we have created the set of policies that all the members of our team are obliged to follow, and that is how we guarantee all of our clients quality and secure services. And, as the policies are available on our website, you can always check them and see how the work is being done at Pro-Papers. Also, as we cannot ask you to simply trust our words, we encourage you to check the feedbacks left by our customers throughout the years, and see what they have to say about our company.
When you make a decision to buy book review from us and place an order on our website, we always make sure that your paper is completed before the assigned deadline. Obviously, the quality of the works is very high anyway, because our team of skilled writers has enough knowledge and experience to complete any task properly when it comes to professional academic writing.
Of course, our paper review service prepares only 100% original content, so that it means that all the works are absolutely plagiarism-free. We have a team of editors who check the paper carefully before it is delivered to you, and that is how we ensure that your work is also error-free. We are aware of the fact that it is hard to find great academic writing services, and therefore all the papers are affordable for everyone due to reduced prices. Also, we are always glad to offer discounts to both our new and loyal customers. Thus, if you need the help with book review assignment, Pro-Papers will gladly provide you with the affordable, quality, and timely assistance. Now, when all your tasks are due soon, you know that there is always a chance to get them done quickly and professionally.
ORDER BOOK REVIEW FROM PRO-PAPERS
If you are extremely busy or simply tired of all the assignments you are constantly given, Pro-Papers will gladly become a solution to your problems. We respect and cherish every single one of you, which is why our book review writing services are always available for you. Our company's online customer support center works 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, which makes ordering exquisite custom written papers much faster and easier. You can go online even in the middle of the night, and our support team members will gladly help you choose the best ordering option, and guide you through the order placement.
We offer excellent book review services to all the students who have no intention to waste their money and want to receive high-quality non-plagiarized works. Our experts have completed numerous assignments over the years, and the works they deliver always keep the customers and their teachers satisfied. Therefore, if you experience some troubles with your paper, order it from us, and let our specialists deliver you the top-notch work.
|Writing from scratch|